Every meeting I have attended this week, it seems, has been focused squarely on one topic: The fiscal cliff.
The last time I remember such widespread concern about a year-end event was in 1999, with the hysteria over "Y2K". As you probably remember, everyone was worried about a global meltdown of IT infrastructure when the calendar moved to the year 2000 due to a widespread software malfunction.
Of course, when midnight came on December 31, 1999, and we started the new year, here's what happened:
Nothing.
And so to this year's event.
The term "fiscal cliff" was apparently first introduced by Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke. Bernanke was discussing the expiration of the combination of tax increases and spending cuts that will occur on January 1, 2013, unless some sort of new budget agreement is reached by Congress and the President by year-end.
Note, however, that if no agreement is reached, the world doesn't necessarily come to an end. Yes, taxes will increase by about $500 billion, and spending cuts of around $100 billion will occur, which will obviously not help improve our fragile economy.
But, unlike the impending doom of Y2K, the economy will not suddenly stop in its tracks on January 1. Even the most bearish economists expect that the economic impact will be mostly a first quarter event.
So will it lead to a recession?
Well, maybe, but consider this commentary from an article titled "3 Reasons to Fade a Fiscal Cliff FreakOut" that appeared on Yahoo! Finance (I added the emphasis):
Michael Darda, chief market strategist at MKM Partners, points out
that no U.S. recession in the past 100 years has occurred without the
Federal Reserve constricting the money supply by either higher interest
rates or other means.
Tighter money is certainly not an element of
today's economy and won't likely be anytime soon, even though rates are
already near zero.
There is also evidence that businesses have already been anticipating
a potential slowdown due to nonproductive talks in Washington, and have
curtailed spending on plant and equipment. This would mean some of the
pain has been front-loaded, and if a palatable budget compromise is
forged, it will uncork pent-up demand early next year. J.P. Morgan Chase
& Co. (JPM)
Chief Executive Jamie Dimon hinted at this prospect last week when he
suggested "the economy can boom" if the fiscal issues are sufficiently
addressed.
Like a steep rise in gasoline prices, the bump in payroll and income
taxes would pressure spending across the economy and reduce its cushion
against another descent into recession, but by no means would it guarantee one.
http://finance.yahoo.com/blogs/the-exchange/3-reasons-fade-fiscal-cliff-freak-162629219.html
Then there's this observation from David Weidner of the Wall Street Journal in a piece titled "Fiscal Cliff is More Hype Than Hazard" :
Really, though, Jan. 1 is simply a deadline set by the Budget Act of
2011.
Washington has a way of fudging deadlines. This particular one is
an extension itself. Moreover, it is a deadline we have been aware of
since a deal to lift the debt ceiling was struck near the end of 2011.
Malleable deadline and budget sequestration don't have that same sexy
ring as fiscal cliff and don't fit nicely in most headlines.
But it is more than that. It is that the temptation to play into fears (and greed) has become too ingrained in the media.
As a result, investors are making decisions based on a tone that is built to grab attention, not inform.
It is almost as irresponsible as threatening a recession to further political interests.
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887324595904578119651900466058.html?KEYWORDS=fiscal+cliff+hype
Finally, even though I find myself quoting Warren Buffett so much these days that I should probably send him a copyright check, he made a couple of comments in an interview on CNN yesterday that are so sensible that I can't resist reprinting them here.
First, to the fiscal cliff, Buffett said:
Buffett shrugged off the Congressional Budget Office's warnings that
failure to address the fiscal cliff by Dec. 31 could lead to a
recession. "We have a very resilient economy," he said. "The fact that
[lawmakers] can't get along for the month of January is not going to
torpedo the economy."
And to the hype that higher tax rates will cripple investment, Buffett said:
Buffett laughed off concerns that higher capital gains taxes could
change how individuals invest in stocks or bonds. "Never in 60 years of
managing money have I come up with an idea and had someone say 'I'd do
it but the tax rates are too high'."
http://money.cnn.com/2012/11/14/investing/buffett-fiscal-cliff/index.html
In short, everyone needs to just take a deep breath, and "chill" a little.
Showing posts with label Fiscal Policy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fiscal Policy. Show all posts
Thursday, November 15, 2012
Wednesday, April 11, 2012
April is the Cruelest Month
Judging from my conversations with friends and colleagues, I must be one of the last people in the United States to prepare my own taxes.
I do this masochistic ritual every spring.
Because I am in the financial advice business, and a good deal of my daily work involves advising clients on tax efficient investment strategies, I feel that it is a good exercise for me to actually get into the nitty-gritty of preparing tax returns.
But what a horrendous experience!
It's not that I actually use pencil and paper to fill out tax forms - Turbo Tax is a marvelous program, and every year it offers new features to try to make the tax preparation experience more bearable.
No, what really makes it hard is trying figure out how best to comply with our federal and state tax laws.
Like most people, I consider myself a fairly honest person, and I try my best to follow the government's rules.
At the same time, I always have the feeling that I am paying too much. Every year, after I have filed my taxes, I always have the uneasy feeling that I have overpaid.
But my limited tax knowledge is the government's gain, I guess.
Turns out that I am not alone in my thoughts about taxes, at least judging from two articles in this morning's New York Times.
Eduardo Porter writes in a column published today:
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/11/business/economy/a-tax-code-of-politics-not-practicality.html?_r=1&wpisrc=nl_wonk
Over the years, there have been countless proposals to change our tax code.
Remember the "flat tax", where returns would be so simple that you could mail them in on postcard?
Or what about the value-added tax (VAT),which is widely used in Europe and is a relatively painless way to gather tax revenue?
Never happened.
As one of my professors at the University of Michigan explained to me years ago, the more efficient the tax code the less opportunity for governments to try to model the behavior of its citizens.
Unfortunately, in our zeal to allow governments to use taxes as a sort of "carrots and sticks" incentive system, our tax code has becomes so perverse and byzantine that only full-time practitioners can really "game" the system.
Take for example the use of private jets by corporate executives.
According to an article written by Steven Davidoff in the Times's "Dealbook" section, it is becoming more common for corporate executives to be able to enjoy the use of a private jet as a tax-free perk even if the flight is for personal use.
How can they do this?
As Mr. Davidoff writes:
... directors often dole out personal safety perks to ease a chief executive’s tax bill. By classifying the benefits as security measures, the executives typically get a better tax treatment on the services.
It’s a common corporate tax trick.
Each year, companies spend millions of dollars to ensure the ostensible safety of their executives, services that sometimes extend to others. Ford, for example, picks up the tab for family members who fly with {Ford CEO Alan} Mulally. The automaker estimated that it spent $178,571 on Mr. Mulally’s and his family’s personal air travel last year. Ford declined to comment.
http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2012/04/10/for-some-corporate-chiefs-private-security-is-a-tax-break/?nl=business&emc=edit_dlbkam_20120411
Hence, to quote TS Elliot, April truly is the cruelest month, at least when it comes to taxes.
I do this masochistic ritual every spring.
Because I am in the financial advice business, and a good deal of my daily work involves advising clients on tax efficient investment strategies, I feel that it is a good exercise for me to actually get into the nitty-gritty of preparing tax returns.
But what a horrendous experience!
It's not that I actually use pencil and paper to fill out tax forms - Turbo Tax is a marvelous program, and every year it offers new features to try to make the tax preparation experience more bearable.
No, what really makes it hard is trying figure out how best to comply with our federal and state tax laws.
Like most people, I consider myself a fairly honest person, and I try my best to follow the government's rules.
At the same time, I always have the feeling that I am paying too much. Every year, after I have filed my taxes, I always have the uneasy feeling that I have overpaid.
But my limited tax knowledge is the government's gain, I guess.
Turns out that I am not alone in my thoughts about taxes, at least judging from two articles in this morning's New York Times.
Eduardo Porter writes in a column published today:
Either you’ve hired an accountant to prepare your tax returns or you’ve
spent countless hours plowing through schedule after schedule, noting
deductions, exemptions and limitations and hoping the software you are
using will get it right. Exhausted and anxious, you’re thinking surely
there must be a better way.
There are, in fact, more efficient ways for government to collect money.
They are much less complicated. And they can raise a lot of revenue to
solve our long-run budget deficit and pay for the increased benefits
demanded by our aging society. What’s more, they can do so without
raising income tax rates. Unfortunately, history suggests we won’t
really consider these alternatives.
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/11/business/economy/a-tax-code-of-politics-not-practicality.html?_r=1&wpisrc=nl_wonk
Over the years, there have been countless proposals to change our tax code.
Remember the "flat tax", where returns would be so simple that you could mail them in on postcard?
Or what about the value-added tax (VAT),which is widely used in Europe and is a relatively painless way to gather tax revenue?
Never happened.
As one of my professors at the University of Michigan explained to me years ago, the more efficient the tax code the less opportunity for governments to try to model the behavior of its citizens.
Unfortunately, in our zeal to allow governments to use taxes as a sort of "carrots and sticks" incentive system, our tax code has becomes so perverse and byzantine that only full-time practitioners can really "game" the system.
Take for example the use of private jets by corporate executives.
According to an article written by Steven Davidoff in the Times's "Dealbook" section, it is becoming more common for corporate executives to be able to enjoy the use of a private jet as a tax-free perk even if the flight is for personal use.
How can they do this?
As Mr. Davidoff writes:
... directors often dole out personal safety perks to ease a chief executive’s tax bill. By classifying the benefits as security measures, the executives typically get a better tax treatment on the services.
It’s a common corporate tax trick.
Each year, companies spend millions of dollars to ensure the ostensible safety of their executives, services that sometimes extend to others. Ford, for example, picks up the tab for family members who fly with {Ford CEO Alan} Mulally. The automaker estimated that it spent $178,571 on Mr. Mulally’s and his family’s personal air travel last year. Ford declined to comment.
http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2012/04/10/for-some-corporate-chiefs-private-security-is-a-tax-break/?nl=business&emc=edit_dlbkam_20120411
Hence, to quote TS Elliot, April truly is the cruelest month, at least when it comes to taxes.
Monday, August 1, 2011
A Tale of Sound and Fury
Cartoon courtesy of Salon.com
For now, at least, it appears that a deal has been reached, and the United States will be able to honor its obligations.
I don't know where you stand on recent events in Washington, but I am relieved that we seem to have reached a resolution. However, I must confess that when I read some of the details of the accord I thought: Was this what all the drama was about?
According to Wikipedia, the total size of the federal budget for fiscal 2011 (which ends on September 30) is expected to be $3.8 trillion, and a deficit of $1.3 trillion. The total size of the spending cuts is supposed to be about $913 billion - but spread over the next decade.
In other words, it took the collective wisdom of all of our elected officials in Washington to agree to cut, on average, $91 billion this year - or about 2% of the total budget.
And there's more: Writing in this morning's Washington Post, Ezra Klein notes that most of the expected cuts are due to come from the defense department - Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid are totally off the table, despite the undeniable truth that these three areas are the major causes of the federal budget deficits:
And that gets to the truth of this deal, and perhaps of Washington in this age: it’s all about lowest-common denominator lawmaking. There are no taxes. No entitlement cuts. No stimulus. No infrastructure. Less in actual, specific deficit reduction than there was in the Simpson-Bowles, Ryan, or Obama plans, and even than there was in the Biden/Cantor or Obama/Boehner talks. The two sides didn’t concede more in order to get more. They conceded almost nothing in order to get a trigger and a process, not to mention avoid a financial catastrophe.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/ezra-klein/post/a-deal-that-found-the-lowest-common-denominator/2011/07/11/gIQAde9TmI_blog.html?hpid=z1
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

